The recent mild drama between Tony Elumelu and his young employee has sparked a public debate on how the old and younger generations view respect, writes JULIANA UCHE-OKOBI.
“Good morning, Tony,” she said. And Tony Elumelu, outgoing Chairman of Heirs Holdings and the United Bank for Africa (UBA), paused in disbelief. Then he found his voice and wanted to know whether the name was even pronounced correctly. “Toyin? Toyin?” he asked. And the lady, who obviously did not understand why her boss repeated the name, went ahead to correct him. “No sir, Tony,” she clarified. In her innocence, she thought she was clearing any doubt concerning the name of her boss but she only succeeded in hitting that part of him he did not want anybody her age to hit. “Okay. No, you won’t call me Tony… You’ll call me ‘Mr. Elumelu’, or ‘TOE’. You won’t call me ‘Tony’, or ‘Chairman’,” the UBA boss said, adding that he would not entertain that “oyinbo” habit.
The above scenario was what played out between Elumelu and a young graduate recently at a graduate management trainee conference of the bank. The brief drama has since elicited comments from Nigerians who either supported or criticised Elumelu’s public reaction.
Was the lady in question disrespectful or simply doing what her generation treats as ordinary? Was the UBA boss right to correct her in public or should a man long addressed as “Tony” across Nigerian business circles have let it go? These questions have been begging for answers since the incident. But it was not the first time that the old and the younger generation have clashed on issues bordering on respect.
Four years ago, precisely in March 2022, a similar incident played out. Mary Chinda, a correspondent with the Arise Television, was reporting live from an airport as evacuated Nigerians filed past behind her, back from a war that had broken out in Ukraine. In the studio anchoring the programme was Reuben Abati, a respected broadcast journalist, former presidential spokesman and former chairman of the editorial board of The Guardian newspaper, with thirty years of experience in the profession.
Within that routine back and forth communication between anchor and reporter, Chinda called him ‘Reuben.’ It landed like a bomb in his ear but the veteran journalist endured it two consecutive times. By the time the reporter called him by the same name the third time, Abati lost his composure. “It seems like you attended my naming ceremony,” he interjected on air. He went further to tell Chinda that he might have to school her on his history in the profession.
Abati’s reaction on air was understandable to the people of his generation even though millennials and Gen Zs might not have seen anything wrong in what Chinda did. For Abati, who felt that he earned the right to be addressed by his titles, young people certainly have issues with etiquette.
But, as it is now the case with the Elumelu matter, Abati’s public correction of Chinda also generated arguments. Those in favour of Chinda believed she had not broken any rule. They argued that the global broadcasting convention, the same convention CNN and the BBC run on, puts anchors and correspondents on first-name terms, precisely because it keeps live television sounding human. They might be right. But Chinda certainly broke a rule; Abati’s rule. That was how those who argued on his side viewed it. They argued that, whatever the format demanded, the veteran could not have forfeited the weight of his career and pedigree just because the genre called for casualness.
The argument about first names being used between older and younger generations is not confined within the boundaries of Nigeria. While addressing an audience some years back in the United States, professor and award-winning writer, Maya Angelou, kicked when a young lady addressed her as just “Maya”. She told the girl she was sixty-two years old, and had earned the right to be called Miss Angelou, or Dr. Angelou, or if warmth was wanted over formality, auntie. Then, almost as an afterthought that turned out to be the real point, she added that the girl was not entirely to blame. Somewhere behind her stood the people who should have taught her better and had not.
The three incidents point to one thing: etiquette. People from the older generation are demanding respect, which they earned, from the younger generation but which the younger generation feels they have given mutually. The issue here is a gap between what one generation assumes respect requires and what the other assumes it embodies and it costs nothing to give.
Titles, in the world that Elumelu, Abati and Angelou and their generation come from, were never decorative. They were shorthand for something built over decades, a record of what a person survived or earned to attain a position they occupy.
When Angelou said she had “earned the right” to be addressed in a certain way, she was not describing entitlement. She was describing her age and a body of work that accompanied it. A first name, to her, flattens all of that into the same currency you would use for a classmate. That was unacceptable to her. Moreover, there is also workplace logic, which has nothing to do with ego. Hierarchy exists in most institutions for a reason. For instance, it signals where decisions sit and whose experience should carry more weight in a room.
Ngozi Uzowuru, a banker, also pointed out the issue of context, which she said should be considered. According to her, Elumelu’s correction happened at a graduate trainee conference, which was a formal public setting and not a one-on-one chat where the same first name he objected to might have passed without a comment. She buttressed her argument by making reference to 2022 when a Stanford Graduate School of Business student reportedly walked up to the same Elumelu and said, “Hi Tony” during a fireside chat. That scenario, Uzowuru said, went without any incident. While Elumelu welcomed the first-name use in that instance, he frowned at it at the recent event. “That’s what I mean by context,” the banker explained.
As some commentators have pointed out, the rules guiding a particular workplace determine how individuals are addressed. In the case of Abati and Chinda, for instance, which was an anchor and field correspondence situation, it was not a Nigerian invention. It was something lifted from American and British network television, where first-name address between anchor and reporter is not viewed as a breach of respect. Instead, it is built to sound like two colleagues talking, not two strangers reading at each other. The CNN anchors use first names, likewise the BBC. But from Abati’s reaction, it could be said that Nigerian broadcasting adopted the format’s rhythm without importing the assumption behind it. Going by that line of argument, Uzowuru opined that Chinda did not break with etiquette but simply followed the etiquette of the genre she was hired to perform in.
The same line of argument was put forward in Elumelu’s case. Some observers pointed out that UBA’s graduate trainee programme has, at times, encouraged first-name culture among young employees, as part of an effort to feel less rigid, closer to the flattened workplace tradition that consulting firms and tech companies have normalised. If that argument stands, the trainee could be said to have only practised what her induction trained her to do, without knowing that the rule had a silent exception at the top.
The case for the elders does not collapse under any of this. But it does get harder to make cleanly, sometimes what looks like insolence is two conventions colliding in real time, with the younger person standing, often without knowing it, in the middle.
Some have blamed the perceived ‘disrespect’of the younger generation on the elders who failed in their role to train the younger ones. That was the opinion of Professor Angelou. Having told the young lady that she had no licence to call her Maya, the professor turned the blame outward toward whoever had raised the girl and never taught her the right thing to do. That small pivot does real work. It refuses to let the story end at “young people today have no manners.”
As Angelou pointed out, manners are taught, not innate. If an entire generation seems to skip formalities their elders once took for granted, the first place to look is not the generation itself but the people who were supposed to model the standard but did not.
Josephine Ike, a secondary school teacher and mother of three, makes the same argument in blunter, more local terms. The real problem, she told our reporter, was not the children but the parents who raised them.
“Mothers now dress like young girls and sometimes even worse. They don’t want anybody to address them as old women or mummy. I have seen children call their parents by their names. So, if they call their parents by their names, how would they think it is wrong to call another person by their first name?” Ike queried.
It is a hard question to argue with. A child who has never once had to call a parent “Mummy” or “Sir” has no internal alarm to trip when the same informality slips out in front of a bank chairman.
Not everyone agrees that the older generation is at fault, however. Kola Alao, a social critic, places the blame on society more broadly, but added a sharper edge to the younger generation’s role in it. Alao said that Gen Z, in his view, does not take correction well, and is shaped less by parents or elders than by whatever it absorbs from the internet. Where Ike sees a home-training failure, Alao sees a generation formed largely offscreen from the adults meant to raise it, raised, in effect, by algorithms rather than aunties and uncles.
Ike and Alao’s arguments are well founded. Investigations have revealed that many Gen X parents grew uncomfortable being addressed formally by their children’s friends, and waved it off in favour of their first name, warmth over distance, they thought at the time. But it meant a cohort of children grew up watching adults opt out of the very titles their own elders would later expect from them in a boardroom or a studio. Nobody explained that the rule would reassert itself once they reached those rooms. The standard shifted mid-generation, quietly, and the same generation that shifted it later stood in a conference hall, visibly startled that the children raised inside that shift had not intuited where the old line still held.
Generational researchers offer a less accusatory frame for the same shift. Gen Z, those born between 1997 and 2012, tend to treat respect as something mutual and earned, rather than something owed automatically to age or title. Such reasoning puts them at odds with older generations who expect deference by default. Raised with constant access to information, they are more inclined to ask “why” behind a rule or fact-check a claim in real time, a habit that reads as curiosity to some and insubordination to others. This, again, is a shift from a world where elders were the only available source of knowledge to one where a phone in every pocket can settle an argument mid-sentence.
In addition to that is a professional culture, largely from Western workplaces and digital spaces, that treats first names as the default register regardless of age or rank, so that the informality that reads as disrespect to one generation, reads simply as how modern institutions function to the other.
Whatever the argument, the case under discussion is not a case for letting the correction slide. Rather, it is a case that the correction often came as a surprise rather than a lesson because the lesson had gone untaught for years, sometimes by the very people delivering it, and because the world the young were actually raised in no longer runs on the assumptions the correction was based on.
The Elumelu incident has since gone past first-name call to something even deeper. That is, what the name was standing in for and who confers it.
For generations, a chieftaincy title in Nigeria meant something specific: a community examining the life of an individual and deciding that the fellow deserved a stool. It was the traditional version of what Angelou was defending: recognition earned across years and granted by people whose judgment carried weight because it was not for sale.
That line of argument is no longer reliably true. The trend now, observers say, is that chieftaincy titles go to whoever can pay, with little inquiry into how the money was made. Ike supports this argument. She said, these days, men with no community record, sometimes with reputations that would once have disqualified them outright, now buy the appearance of a status they would normally have had to earn over a lifetime. “Once the cash is in hand, nobody asks the harder questions,” she said.
Like social titles, politics runs on the same pattern through a different door. The costs of nomination forms for elective office in Nigeria have climbed to figures most aspirants can not raise alone. This has birthed godfathers who bankroll political ambitions and who also determine what happens when the aspirant eventually makes it into office.
The two instances clearly produced a pattern. Elumelu, Abati and Angelou were each defending something that could only be earned. But, elsewhere, in the same culture, at the same moment, that currency is being quietly replaced by a simpler one. Wealth does not ask permission the way a first name does. It purchases the title outright. Oftentimes, the very elders who would bristle at being called by their first name are the ones signing off on the transaction, a stool for a fee, a nomination for a wire transfer.
Viewed from all sides, the two controversies are not separate stories. They are the same argument, just in different currencies. What a name costs to use, what a title costs to buy and, in both, what is actually at stake is whether standing has to be earned at all or whether it can simply be paid for.
In the meantime, Elumelu and the girl in question have reportedly mended fences. Although the ‘reconciliation’ was not confirmed by the UBA or the boss himself, the incident has, ironically, put the girl on the path of fame and fortune.
Within the same week the internet was aflame with the “Good-morning-Tony” incident, Ossai Ovie Success, Senior Special Assistant on Media to Delta State Governor, Sheriff Oborevwori, announced on Facebook that he was stepping in on the trainee’s behalf. He offered her ₦500,000 in cash support, a brand ambassador role for the fourth Delta Social Media Summit, and an all-expenses-paid VIP trip to Asaba, including flights, five-star accommodation and a guided tour of state projects, ahead of the summit on August 27, 2026.
Success framed it explicitly as pushback against pile-on culture rather than a verdict on the underlying etiquette question. Although Success thanked Elumelu for “pointing out the needed correction,” he argued that the online punishment had gone far past the offence. As at press time, the trainee had not publicly confirmed whether she had accepted the offer.
From all the arguments, it is clear that Gen Z has not pushed tradition aside. The elders, too, have not entirely failed in their duty to teach the younger generation what they should know. What Angelou’s lecture hall, Abati’s studio, Elumelu’s conference floor, the chieftaincy stools sold rather than earned and the nomination forms bankrolled rather than won actually show is narrower and more useful than either accusation.
It shows that the old signals of respect, which include a title, a formal name, a stool and an office, still matter to the people who built their standing around them. And for young professionals, Alao advised that they should “form the habit of reading a room,” which he explained to mean paying attention and being willing to recalibrate the moment they go wrong.

