A crisis of confidence is brewing in the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) Regional Competition Authority (ERCA) following a controversial proposal to introduce a cap on merger notification fees across West Africa markets.
Nigeria’s Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC) is a member of the ERCA.
At stake is a disagreement over modality for revenue allocation, regulatory jurisdiction and the level of institutional control by ERCA’s headquarter in Gambia over member states numbering 12.
The proposal, which seeks to put a cap at $500,000 for fees payable by applicants, will vest more control and resources at the ERCA secretariat.
Members like Nigeria, Ghana, Sierra Leone and Liberia are uncomfortable with the idea.
Nigeria accounts for about 41 per cent of West Africa’s gross domestic product.
Consequently, a uniform cap could have a disproportionate financial impact on Nigeria which accounts for the overwhelming proportion of the region’s notifiable merger transactions, while leaving unresolved how national regulators would be compensated for their structural responsibilities.
Sources familiar with development confirmed that things took a dramatic turn two weeks ago when the proposal was formally tabled during ERCA’s 13th statutory meeting in Conakry, Guinea.
“The memo to that effect was emailed to us just ten minutes before the meeting started in a manner that looks like an ambush,” one of the sources said.
The five countries called for the matter to be stood down to allow due consultations with their respective national institutions before taking a collective position.
Although proponents argue that the cap would reduce compliance costs and make regional merger notifications more predictable for businesses, opposition to the proposal centres on far-reaching financial and institutional implications.
A major concern is that regional merger filings could displace existing national filing arrangements and their associated revenues without a clearly defined mechanism for sharing regulatory responsibilities, operational costs or proceeds between ERCA and domestic competition authorities.
Opponents also argue that the proposal raised fundamental questions about ERCA’s jurisdiction and its relationship with national competition authorities, particularly where transactions derive more than 70 per cent of their turnover from a particular member state’s market or substantially affect domestic competition.
The concerns are compounded by the fact that most ECOWAS member states have neither ratified the relevant regional competition protocols nor signed the memoranda of understanding required to operationalise them.
Many also lack established national competition authorities capable of independently assessing the economic and regulatory implications of the proposed cap.
Efforts to get the reaction of the FCCPC were unsuccessful as its spokesman, Mr. Ondaje Ijagwu, did not pick his calls nor respond to text messages.
Credit: The Nation

