The Federal High Court in Abuja has ordered the extradition of a Nigerian, Temitope Seyi Omotade, to the United States to face trial over alleged mail fraud, wire fraud, conspiracy and aggravated identity theft.
Justice Peter Lifu gave the order while delivering judgment in an extradition suit filed by the Attorney-General of the Federation, who sought Omotade’s surrender to the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota.
The judge held that the Federal Government had satisfied the statutory requirements for extradition under the Extradition Act, dismissing the respondent’s objections to the application.
Omotade is wanted in the US over a superseding five-count indictment filed on February 8, 2022, in case number 22-CR-24 SRN/HB.
The first three counts involve alleged mail fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit the offences, contrary to Sections 1341, 1343 and 1349 of Title 18 of the United States Code. Each count carries a maximum penalty of 30 years’ imprisonment.
The remaining two counts relate to aggravated identity theft and aiding and abetting, offences punishable by up to two years’ imprisonment each, in addition to any other sentence imposed.
In its application, the Attorney-General argued that the extradition request was supported by formal diplomatic communications from the US government, a sealed indictment issued by the Minnesota court and a warrant for Omotade’s arrest.
The government maintained that all legal requirements had been met, stressing that the alleged offences were not political or trivial and that the request was made in good faith.
It also told the court that the extradition documents included properly certified affidavits from US officials, relevant statutory provisions and passport details.
The AGF further argued that there were no pending criminal proceedings against Omotade in Nigeria over the offences and that adequate assurances had been obtained regarding his treatment and trial in the US.
However, Omotade, through his lawyer, urged the court to dismiss the application, denying any involvement in mail fraud, wire fraud, conspiracy or aggravated identity theft.
He maintained that his association with one Roxanne Gilbert did not involve any criminal agreement or proceeds from illegal digital transactions.
Challenging the evidence presented by the Federal Government, Omotade argued that the extradition documents contained no blockchain analysis, financial transaction records, chat histories or video-call evidence linking him to the alleged offences.
He contended that the materials relied upon by the prosecution were largely limited to identification documents, including passport details and an airway bill, which he said were insufficient to establish his involvement in the alleged crimes.
He also raised concerns about possible identity theft by third parties.
In addition, Omotade cited his health condition, telling the court that he was receiving specialist medical treatment for hepatic steatosis, commonly known as fatty liver, and elevated liver enzyme levels.
He argued that his extradition would be unjust and oppressive, considering his medical condition and the physical demands associated with international transfer and detention.
But Justice Lifu rejected the arguments, holding that the medical evidence presented did not sufficiently establish that extradition would expose Omotade to grave and unavoidable health risks.
The judge noted that the respondent had failed to demonstrate that adequate medical care would be unavailable in the US or that his condition would make his surrender practically unjust or oppressive.
“In the absence of sufficient evidence establishing the asserted degree of risk, I am unable to hold that the respondent’s medical condition, standing alone, constitutes a legal bar to surrender in this case,” the judge held.
Justice Lifu also dismissed claims that any statutory restriction under Section 3 of the Extradition Act prevented Omotade’s surrender.
He said there was no sufficient evidence that the extradition request was intended to prosecute or punish him on account of his race, religion, nationality or political opinions.
The judge emphasised that extradition proceedings were not intended to determine the guilt or innocence of a person sought by another country but to establish whether the legal conditions for surrender had been satisfied.
According to him, Omotade would retain the right to challenge the allegations against him under the laws and procedures applicable to the criminal proceedings in the US.
“The purpose of extradition proceedings is not to determine the respondent’s guilt in advance, nor to deprive him of the protections available under the law.
“It is to ensure that a request for surrender is examined judicially and that the person sought is surrendered only where the applicable statutory requirements have been satisfied,” he said.
Consequently, the judge ordered Omotade’s extradition to the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota to answer the five-count indictment.
Justice Lifu also dismissed his bail application, which was filed on September 16.

